Mustard Herring Without Cream
1970s · typewriter
20 min prep · 25 min cook
herringmustardpickledjewishmake-aheadegg-yolksmayonnaiseno-creamtraditional
Ingredients
- 1.herrings, 8–12; soaked overnight in cold water; water changed a few times; filleted and skinned
- 2.500 millilitre white vinegar, for brine
- 3.15 millilitre mustard powder, dry
- 4.310 millilitre sugar
- 5.7 bay leaves
- 6.8 black peppercorns, whole
- 7.2 garlic, 2 big cloves; minced
- 8.8 egg yolks, beaten in mixer with whisk until thick and creamy
- 9.250 millilitre mayonnaise, folded in at end
- 10.1.25 millilitre black pepper, freshly ground; mixed through at end
- 11.onions, 4–5; sliced; for layering
Method
- 1.Soak the herring overnight in cold water. Change water a few times to remove saltiness.
- 2.Combine vinegar, mustard powder, sugar, bayleaves, peppercorns and garlic. Bring to the boil and remove from stove.
- 3.Beat egg yolks in mixer with whisk until thick and creamy. Strain the vinegar mixture and slowly add to the yolks, beating all the time.
- 4.Place mixture in double boiler on stove. Cook slowly till sauce thickens — approx 15 minutes. Then place directly on heat and bring to the boil. Remove from heat immediately.
- 5.Fold in the mayonnaise. Mix through pepper and leave to cool.
- 6.If necessary, add an extra ¼ cup vinegar to get right consistency. Mix well.
- 7.Place alternate layers of herring and onions in a dish. Pour over sauce and refrigerate for a few days.
Notes
- A richer, more substantial sauce than the cream-based Mustard Herring — egg yolks and mayonnaise give a thick, coating consistency.
- The double boiler method for the egg-yolk sauce prevents curdling.
- Note: an identical recipe appears twice in the scan — only one copy retained.