Mustard Herring
1970s · typewriter
20 min prep · 15 min cook
herringmustardcreampickledjewishmake-aheadrefrigerator-pickletraditional
Ingredients
- 1.6 herrings, soaked; filleted; do not skin; cut into serving portions
- 2.onion, sliced; for layering
- 3.250 millilitre white vinegar, for brine
- 4.250 millilitre water, for brine
- 5.bay leaves and peppercorns, a few bayleaves; a handful of peppercorns
- 6.3 eggs, whole; beaten
- 7.60 millilitre sugar
- 8.7.5 millilitre mustard powder, dry
- 9.250 millilitre thick cream, whipped lightly
Method
- 1.Fillet but do not skin the herring. Cut into serving portions. Layer the herring portions and the sliced onions in a casserole. Set aside.
- 2.Boil up the vinegar, water, bayleaves and peppercorns. Cool.
- 3.Beat very well the eggs, the sugar and the mustard. Add the egg mixture to the cooled vinegar mixture.
- 4.Bring to the boil, stirring constantly until thick. Cool and strain.
- 5.Whip the cream lightly. Fold the cooled vinegar-egg mixture into the cream.
- 6.Pour this sauce over the layered herring and onion. Cover and allow to pickle for 3–4 days.
Notes
- Method spans two pages in the original binder (page 7 for ingredients and method start, page 16 for method continuation).
- This version uses whole eggs and thick cream — compare with Mustard Herring Without Cream (also in this collection) which uses egg yolks and mayonnaise.
- The egg-cream sauce is cooked to thicken it before being folded with cream — this gives a richer result.